Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Nonviolent Resistance...My Response to the Schadenfreude Demonstrated Upon Osama Bin Laden's Death

Tuesday, May 3, 2011 at 6:40pm



The method of nonviolent resistance is effective in that it has a way of disarming the opponent, it exposes his moral defenses, it weakens his morale and at the same time it works on his conscience. 

It also makes it possible for the individual to struggle to secure moral ends through moral means. One of the most persistent philosophical debates of the centuries has been over the question of ends and means. There have been those from Machiavelli on down who have argued that the end justifies the means. This, I feel, is one of the greatest tragedies of communism. Read Lenin as he says, "lying, deceit, and violence are justifiable means to bring about the end of a classless society." This is where nonviolence breaks with communism and any other method which contends that the end justifies the means. In a real sense, the means represent the ideal in the making and the end in process. So in the long run destructive means cannot bring about constructive ends, because the end is preexistent in the means. 

This is the beauty of nonviolence. It says you can struggle without hating; you can fight war without violence. Nonviolent resistance also provides a creative force through which men can channelize their discontent. It does not require that they abandon their discontent. This discontent is sound and healthy. Nonviolence saves it from degenerating into morbid bitterness and hatred. Hate is always tragic. It is as injurious to the hater as it is to the hated. It distorts the personality and scars the soul. Psychiatrists are telling us now that many of the inner conflicts and strange things that happen in the subconscious are rooted in hate. So they are now saying,

"Love or perish."  

This is the beauty of nonviolence. It says you can struggle without hating; you can fight war without violence. 

It is my great hope that as the Negro plunges deeper into the quest for freedom, he will plunge even deeper into the philosophy of nonviolence. As a race we must work passionately and unrelentingly for first-class citizenship, but we must never use second-class methods to gain it. We must never succumb to the temptation of using violence in the struggle, for if this happens, unborn generations will be the recipients of a long and desolate night of bitterness and our chief legacy to the future will be an endless reign of meaningless chaos. 

I feel that this way of nonviolence is vital because it is the only way toreestablish the broken community. it is the method which seeks to implement the just law by appealing to the conscience of the great decent majority who through blindness, fear, pride, or irrationality have allowed their consciences to sleep. 

The nonviolent resisters can summarize their message in the following simple terms: We will take direct action against injustice without waiting for other agencies to act. We will not obey unjust laws or submit to unjust practices. We will do this peacefully, openly, cheerfully because our aim is to persuade. We adopt the means of nonviolence because our end is a community at peace with itself. We will try to persuade with our words, but if our words fail, we will try to persuade with our acts. We will always be willing to talk and seek fair compromise, but we are ready to suffer when necessary and even risk our lives to become witnesses to the truth as we see it. 

This approach to the problem is not without successful precedent. We have the magnificent example of Gandhi who challenged the might of the British Empire and won independence for his people by using only the weapons of truth, non-injury, courage, and soul force.


This is all an excerpt from one of my favorite speeches by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. It was given as an address to the National Press Club in Washington DC, July 19th, 1962. I feel that more than ever, the message of Dr. King's speech is still relevant today. In a time, when people are celebrating the death and violent destruction of Osama Bin Laden, I feel a dissatisfaction within myself and for the obscene joy and revelry that my fellow countrymen are exibiting. Hate begets hate. Violence will only give birth to more violence and bitterness within us. There are better -more powerful ways of fighting injustice in the world. Through love, understanding, compassion for others, living with *humanistic* values, and nonviolent resistance to the injustices of the world, we can make this world a better -more peaceful place. 
 ·  · Share · Delete
    • Edgar J. Medina 
      My Dear Vanessa, I love you dearly and I value and respect your opinion. I also respect and value the teachings of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. I lived through that era and I had the priviliedge of listening to many of his speeches. He was a true humanitarian and a great American. However, now I must speak as a U.S. Marine veteran and as a Correctional Peace Officer. Unfortunately, there are many people who do not respect the rights of others and who will impose their evil tyrany against them. The world has had its share of evil men through out the ages. Adolph Hitler, Benito Musolini, Lenin, Stalin and many more have plagued humanity with their quest for dominance. If not for nations taking up arms and opposing those evil men we would not be free. Don't get me wrong, I love peace and as a Christian I believe in "turning the other cheek", however, due to this being an inperfect world and the existance of evil I feel that is not moraly wrong to take up arms and fight against evil. That is why I support your cousin (my son's) military mission. That is why I proudly served in Vietnam and that is why I work as a Correctional Officer in maximum security prison. I believe in peace and I try to use nonviolent means to deal with situations. However, what kind of man would I be if I allowed an intruder to break into my house and hurt my wife and children while I had the means to stop him because I believe in non violence. To me that would be cowardice. I can understand how it might seem offensive to you when people were rejoicing and celebrating the death of Osama Bin Ladin. However, I don't think that I'm obscene for feeling relief, pride (in our brave military) and joy knowing that this evil man will not be plotting or urging others to kill inocent people. I wish there were many more people like you and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr
      May 3 at 10:43pm ·  ·  1 person
    • Edgar J. Medina Yet, sadly, the world is what it is and we need law enforcement and the military to protect our freedoms and our lives.
      May 3 at 10:51pm ·  ·  1 person
    • Vanessa Medina 
      Uncle Edgar J. Medina, I love and respect you deeply. And I am grateful for your contributions to our country, as well as Mark Christian Medina's contributions. I sincerely hope that you do not misunderstand what I am saying here. Never, have I considered you to be *obscene*. I used that word to describe the cheering and over the top jubilation that I had seen in responce to Bin Laden's death -not *you*. I can understand your feelings of relief and pride. I think that is perfectly fine. What I am primarily addressing is our attitudes towards our human conflicts. Ideas of *Justice* and *Revenge*...*Us* vs. *them*. I feel a deep dissatisfaction with how violent and destructive our species is and I truly believe that we have the power within ourselves to come together an help form a more peaceful and connected world. Please read this article: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/pamela-gerloff/the-psychology-of-revenge_b_856184.html?ref=fb&src=sp I think it summarizes a lot of my feelings well, and may help you understand a little bit more where I am coming from. I love you Uncle. And I'm grateful that you shared your feelings on this with me. Even if we don't fully agree. I'm glad to have the opportunity to have this dialogue with you.
      May 4 at 8:22pm · 
    • Jodi Arata I love the concept -- but also don't quite see a humanistic way to deal with people who are crazy. I wish we had captured him instead, but that would have inevitably ended in his being hanged (like Sadam). I just don't know! I love you because I know you are driven by this kind of logic, and that makes you such a powerfully positive force.
      May 4 at 9:44pm ·  ·  1 person
    • Catherine Loftus I totally agree. I'm a great believer in nonviolent resistance. Dr. King's words are so moving; he had such a beautiful spirit. We sure could use another MLK today, living in the troubled times that we do. I couldn't believe the footage I saw of people partying after bin Laden's death!
      May 5 at 12:06am ·  ·  1 person
    • Edgar J. Medina 
      Dear Vanessa, I was not offended by the expression of your feelings nor do I think I missunderstood where you are coming from. I was sincere when I wrote that I wish there were more people like you and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. in the world. I celebrate the uniqueness of persons such as Mother Teresa and Dr. Livingston. There are many people whose lives have been inspirational and give me hope. Personaly, as a Christian, I admire the life of Jesus Christ, and the example he set for humanity. Yet, more importantly, I trust him and His teachings with my eternal soul. Unfortuantely, as the bible teaches we live in a "fallen" world because of sin. Therefore, I do not put my faith in humankind to change. Does that mean, that I have given up? No, I still pray for our nation and all of humanity. I still try to live by the "Golden Rule", and I try to make difference. Yet, I believe, that without Christ and the power of the Holy Spirit, it is all in vain. Need to go now but, will write more later. Love you.
      May 5 at 11:42am ·  ·  1 person
    • Vanessa Medina I love you too Uncle Edgar J. Medina! :)
      May 5 at 5:36pm · 

No comments:

Post a Comment